(A personal note before you read the article...I've always envied a tree, especially the hemlocks and the white pine trees. Trees are beautiful and a wonder of nature and for some it is a case of "you don't know what you've got till its gone".)
SENEY NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE, Mich. -- Tracy Casselman runs a hand over the smooth, gray bark of an American beech, noting the scratch marks left by black bears that have clambered up the tree to munch its nuts, rich in fat and protein.
Perhaps 80 years old, a couple of feet in diameter and 60 feet high, the beech appears robust, like many of its neighbors scattered near a two-track road in the backcountry of Michigan's Upper Peninsula. But appearances are deceiving. These trees likely are doomed.
"Take a good look," says Casselman, manager of the Seney National Wildlife Refuge. "In five years, these trees won't be here."
Beech bark disease has taken hold in the refuge, a dagger aimed at the heart of a stalwart native hardwood. The American beech has relatively little economic value for people but plays a starring role in the natural drama acted out daily in Michigan's northern forests.
Scientists expect the disease eventually will kill most of the state's beeches, changing the environment in ways as yet uncertain. For example, it could affect populations of bears and smaller mammals that feed on beech nuts _ and that hunters enjoy pursuing.
"Obviously there will be a shift in the ecology of the forest," says Robert Heyd, forest health specialist with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources in Marquette.
Beech bark disease has been overshadowed by the emerald ash borer, a murderous insect wreaking havoc on trees in southeastern Michigan and creeping steadily northward.
But both have something in common with the zebra mussel, purple loosestrife, round goby and spiny water flea: They are foreign species, introduced to the Great Lakes region through human carelessness, and are crowding out natives and profoundly altering the ecosystem.
"When I was in college, I could name maybe half a dozen exotics," Casselman says. "Now I could spend 10 minutes rattling them off. I just wonder when people are going to recognize the cost of bringing all these exotics in."
Federal studies say more than $120 billion is spent yearly in the United States controlling about 800 invasive species and repairing their damage. And the environmental losses _ extinction of native plants and animals, less biodiversity and natural beauty _ are incalculable.
Debate continues over preventing new invasions through measures such as limits on ballast water dumping by foreign ships in Great Lakes ports. Tighter controls on ornamental plant imports would be helpful, says Michael Lusk, invasive species coordinator for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, who inspected stricken beech trees at Seney last fall.
"In Australia and New Zealand, you can't bring in anything until you prove it is not going to be invasive, it won't hurt what's already there," Lusk says. "Our laws say you can bring in anything you want and once we have a problem, you put it on a list and stop importing it."
Beech bark disease slipped into North America in 1890, courtesy of ornamental trees shipped from Europe to Nova Scotia. Over the next century and more, it moved across eastern Canada and south to New England, New York, Pennsylvania and West Virginia. Spot infestations have turned up even farther away, including Ohio.
The disease was discovered in Michigan in 2000. It was first noticed in Ludington State Park on Lake Michigan and in Bass Lake State Forest Campground near McMillan in the Upper Peninsula, which suggests it could have arrived in firewood brought by campers from elsewhere _ also a likely culprit in the emerald ash borer's movement.
Once established, beech bark disease can be spread by the wind, birds and animals that brush against infected trees.
"It can kill 75 to 80 percent of the (beech) trees in a given area," Lusk says. "Once it's there, it's everywhere. You're done, you're cooked."
Beech bark disease actually happens in two stages.
It begins with tiny scale insects that feed on sap in the tree's thin bark. Heavily infested beeches are noticeable by the white wax that covers the scales, creating a woolly appearance.
The scale injures the beeches, making them vulnerable to a fungus called nectria that kills tissue and often entire trees.
Heavy winds sometimes cause "beech snap," in which weakened trunks break in half. To protect hikers, authorities removed more than 200 beeches along trails at Tahquamenon Falls State Park, says Deborah McCullough, forest entomology professor at Michigan State University.
Beech are not the most prevalent of Michigan hardwoods. They're found most often within areas classified as maple-beech-birch, which make up about 7.2 million acres of the state's 20 million acres of forestland, Heyd said. In such areas, maple and birch tend to outnumber beech, which grows primarily in the northern Lower Peninsula and eastern Upper Peninsula.
There's no readily available substitute for beech nuts as a food source in the 95,238-acre Seney wildlife refuge in Schoolcraft County, a patchwork of woods, fields and wetlands teeming with waterfowl.
Managers acknowledge they don't know how the loss of most or all beech trees would affect the refuge's animal populations.
"Bears are omnivores, so I don't expect a big impact on them," staff forester Greg Corace says, gazing at a snapped-off beech in an area infested with the invasive scale. "But some species may be less adaptable. We just don't know what will happen, but we suspect it isn't going to be good."
On the Net:
U.S. Forest Service beech bark disease site: http://www.na.fs.fed.us/fhp/bbd/
Seney National Wildlife Refuge: http://www.fws.gov/Midwest/Seney/
- Cathy Clementz
- A long time ago, I was a child. (I started out as Cathy First from Colon, Mi.) For the past several years I’ve been an adult. A lot of things went on between those two stages of life; probably no more or no less than anyone elses. My husband and I moved to “da U .P” from southern Lower Michigan several years ago (yes we were trolls at one time). We owned and operated and operate Clementz’s Northcountry Campground and Cabins just north of Newberry, Michigan until May 2015. We have grown kids and grandkids (who all live downstate). My passion is life and all that Nature has to offer us and trying to photograph it in unique ways. Our intention in life is to see all that Nature has to offer us. We hope that you will be a part of our adventures as we cruise through our lives together. Come back often!